Who would dare choose one over the other? Here’s the latest on Twitter as ex-Manchester United’s Vidic and Liverpool’s Van Dijk fans clash.
In case you missed it, Nemanja Vidic and Virgil Van Dijk are being compared on Twitter to establish who was the more complete Center-back in Premier League history. Vidic played for Manchester United between 2006-2014 winning five Premier League titles under head coach Sir Alex Ferguson. Virgil Van Dijk has been Liverpool’s most reliable defender in recent years since joining from Southampton in 2018.
How Did the Comparison Between Van Dijk and Vidic Begin?
On Twitter in 2019, Sky Sports polled users to determine the greatest Premier League center-back of all time.
In the quarterfinals and semifinals, Van Dijk beat Tony Adams and Vincent Kompany, in the quarter-finals and semi-finals respectively.
But in the final poll, Vidic edged him 45% to 55%.
Here we go, it's the final! 🏆
— Sky Sports News (@SkySportsNews) September 11, 2019
We've had hundreds of thousands of votes and we're down to our final 2⃣…
Who wins the Premier League's greatest ever centre-back award? 🤔
The conversation came to life in recent days and here are some of the best reactions to Sky Sports football pundit Jamie Carragher’s comment on Center-backs on Monday.
Van Dijk is not even the Premier League’s best ever Dutch centre-back which is Jaap Stam.
— Sam Pilger (@sampilger) April 10, 2023
One fan argued that Van Dijk is not even the best Dutch Center-back the Premier League had ever seen; depending on your knowledge of football history, are you aware of former Manchester United defender Jaap Stam?
I genuinely wouldn't take much notice on @Carra23 opinion on CB's. He told everyone Martinez would flop without watching him because he was small. Martinez currently the best CB in the league on a debut season. Sit down
— Mark Goldbridge (@markgoldbridge) April 10, 2023
Former Manchester United teammate Rio Ferdinand was also quick off his blocks.
🗣️Rio Ferdinand: “I see Jamie Carragher tweeted something about Van Dijk being better than Vidic. I think Torres scored three goals in 15 games against Vidic. It's a myth.”
— Football Talk (@FootballTalkHQ) April 11, 2023
Nemanja Vidić in the Premier League:
🎖️ The first defender to be named Player of the Season
🎖️ The only… pic.twitter.com/9bEQi6X5Ru
Vidic vs van Dijk in The Premier League
— Football Factly (@FootballFactly) April 10, 2023
Games: 211-220
Goals Conceded: 133-202
Clean Sheet: 95-90
Blocks: 139-111
Interceptions: 368-338
Tackles: 363-225
Tackles Won: 274-153
Clearances: 2,232-1,133
Headed Clearances: 1,385-634
Error Leading Goal: 3-4
Vidic 11-0 van Dijk. pic.twitter.com/hfjWVnpBaJ
Subscribe to Switch TV for more exciting content
— Emma (@UTDEmma_) April 10, 2023
Well now you can decide who’s the better center-back between Nemanja Vidic and Virgil Van Dijk
Read Also: Pep Guardiola calls on Michael Jordan as inspiration ahead of Champions League quarterfinal